BibTex Citation Data :
@article{MMH84053, author = {Nisrina Arum Agavi and Ridwan Ridwan and Muhamad Romdoni}, title = {BETWEEN LEGALITY AND PROPORTIONALITY: JUDICIAL DEPARTURES FROM SPECIAL MINIMUM SENTENCES IN INDONESIAN NARCOTICS CASES}, journal = {Masalah-Masalah Hukum}, volume = {55}, number = {2}, year = {2026}, keywords = {Narcotics Sentencing; Special Minimum Penalties; Judicial Discretion; Proportionality; Below-Minimum Sentencing}, abstract = { Indonesia’s narcotics regime combines severe penalties with special minimum terms for possession and illicit distribution offences. These minimums aim to promote consistency and deterrence, but rigid application may produce disproportionate sentences where proven conduct and culpability differ from the charged offence’s typical profile. This article examines judicial departures from special minimum penalties through Supreme Court Decision No. 6326 K/Pid.Sus/2025. It asks whether, and under what conditions, the Supreme Court may uphold imprisonment below the five-year minimum prescribed by Article 114(1) of Law No. 35 of 2009 on Narcotics. The study employs doctrinal legal research using statutory, case, and conceptual approaches. It analyses the Narcotics Law, the Judicial Power Law, relevant Supreme Court Circular Letters, the 2023 Criminal Chamber formulation, and scholarship on legality, discretion, and proportionality. The decision imposed two years and six months’ imprisonment, a fine of IDR 1 billion-, and three-months’ subsidiary imprisonment. This raises a specific issue: the custodial term falls below Article 114(1)’s minimum, while the fine corresponds to its statutory minimum. The article finds that Supreme Court guidance provides a narrow basis for departure in exceptional cases involving small quantities and evidence of personal use or reduced participation, while preserving the statutory fine where required. However, authority to depart does not establish that a particular sentence is adequately justified. The decision’s precedential value is limited if its reasoning fails to connect the charge, narcotics type and net weight, purpose, defendant’s role, transaction context, lower-court findings, and cassation grounds to the reduced sentence. The article proposes a structured, fact-sensitive test to make departures transparent, reviewable, and consistent. It concludes that proportionality may qualify statutory minimums only within a recognised legal framework and through reasoned decisions that preserve legality and constrain arbitrary sentencing. }, issn = {2527-4716}, pages = {444--468} doi = {10.14710/mmh.55.2.2026.444-468}, url = {https://ejournal.undip.ac.id/index.php/mmh/article/view/84053} }
Refworks Citation Data :
Indonesia’s narcotics regime combines severe penalties with special minimum terms for possession and illicit distribution offences. These minimums aim to promote consistency and deterrence, but rigid application may produce disproportionate sentences where proven conduct and culpability differ from the charged offence’s typical profile. This article examines judicial departures from special minimum penalties through Supreme Court Decision No. 6326 K/Pid.Sus/2025. It asks whether, and under what conditions, the Supreme Court may uphold imprisonment below the five-year minimum prescribed by Article 114(1) of Law No. 35 of 2009 on Narcotics. The study employs doctrinal legal research using statutory, case, and conceptual approaches. It analyses the Narcotics Law, the Judicial Power Law, relevant Supreme Court Circular Letters, the 2023 Criminal Chamber formulation, and scholarship on legality, discretion, and proportionality. The decision imposed two years and six months’ imprisonment, a fine of IDR 1 billion-, and three-months’ subsidiary imprisonment. This raises a specific issue: the custodial term falls below Article 114(1)’s minimum, while the fine corresponds to its statutory minimum. The article finds that Supreme Court guidance provides a narrow basis for departure in exceptional cases involving small quantities and evidence of personal use or reduced participation, while preserving the statutory fine where required. However, authority to depart does not establish that a particular sentence is adequately justified. The decision’s precedential value is limited if its reasoning fails to connect the charge, narcotics type and net weight, purpose, defendant’s role, transaction context, lower-court findings, and cassation grounds to the reduced sentence. The article proposes a structured, fact-sensitive test to make departures transparent, reviewable, and consistent. It concludes that proportionality may qualify statutory minimums only within a recognised legal framework and through reasoned decisions that preserve legality and constrain arbitrary sentencing.
Article Metrics:
Last update:
Last update: 2026-11-21 11:49:45
The Authors submitting a manuscript do so on the understanding that if accepted for publication, copyright of the article shall be assigned to Masalah Masalah Hukum journal (MMH) and Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro as publisher of the journal. Copyright encompasses rights to reproduce and deliver the article in all form and media, including reprints, photographs, microfilms, and any other similar reproductions, as well as translations.
MMH journal and Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro and the Editors make every effort to ensure that no wrong or misleading data, opinions or statements be published in the journal. In any way, the contents of the articles and advertisements published in MMH journal are the sole responsibility of their respective authors and advertisers.
We strongly encourage that manuscripts be submitted to online journal system in http://ejournal.undip.ac.id/index.php/mmh/index. Authors are required to create an account and submit the manuscripts online. For submission inquiries, please follow the submission instructions in the website. If the author has any problems on the online submission, please contact Editorial Office at the following email: jurnal.mmh@undip.ac.id or jurnal.mmh@gmail.com
Contributors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce any materials, including photographs and illustrations, for which they do not hold the copyright and for ensuring that the appropriate acknowledgments are included in the manuscript.