BibTex Citation Data :
@article{MMH86554, author = {Jelita Kristi Agape and Adi Sulistyono and Muhammad Rustamaji}, title = {RESTORATIVE JUSTICE OR ‘RESTORATIVE INJUSTICE’? EXAMINING NORMATIVE LIMITATIONS IN INDONESIA’S NEW PENAL CODE ON ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMIC CRIMES}, journal = {Masalah-Masalah Hukum}, volume = {55}, number = {2}, year = {2026}, keywords = {Restorative Justice; Restorative Injustice; Environmental Criminal Law; Corporate Criminal Liability; Ecological Justice}, abstract = { This article critically examines the application of restorative justice in Indonesian environmental criminal law under Law No. 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code and Law No. 32 of 2009 on Environmental Protection and Management. It focuses on how restorative justice may be transformed into “restorative injustice” in cases involving corporate environmental crimes and structural ecological damage. Although restorative justice is normatively supported by the purposes of sentencing set out in Article 51 and reflected in Articles 52–54 of the Criminal Code, its implementation in environmental cases may depart from these objectives. In particular, restoration may be understood as procedural settlement or financial compensation rather than scientifically verifiable ecological recovery. This study employs doctrinal legal research through statutory and conceptual approaches, drawing on green criminology, ecological justice, and critical legal studies to assess the coherence of the restorative justice framework with the characteristics of environmental crime. The analysis shows that environmental crimes differ from conventional offenses because they affect collective and diffuse victims, cause irreversible ecological degradation, and generate long-term public consequences. Such harms cannot be adequately remedied through negotiated settlements alone. The findings indicate that restorative mechanisms may legitimize corporate impunity when No. compensation is prioritized over ecological restoration and corporate accountability, notwithstanding the corporate criminal liability provisions under Law No. 32 of 2009. This article therefore develops the concept of “restorative injustice” to describe a condition in which justice is formally and procedurally achieved but substantively fails to restore ecological balance, secure corporate accountability, protect environmental sustainability, or safeguard the rights and welfare of present and future generations. It argues that restorative justice in environmental criminal law must be assessed not merely by settlement procedures or compensation payments, but by measurable ecological outcomes, meaningful accountability, and the protection of affected communities and ecosystems. }, issn = {2527-4716}, pages = {417--443} doi = {10.14710/mmh.55.2.2026.417-443}, url = {https://ejournal.undip.ac.id/index.php/mmh/article/view/86554} }
Refworks Citation Data :
This article critically examines the application of restorative justice in Indonesian environmental criminal law under Law No. 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code and Law No. 32 of 2009 on Environmental Protection and Management. It focuses on how restorative justice may be transformed into “restorative injustice” in cases involving corporate environmental crimes and structural ecological damage. Although restorative justice is normatively supported by the purposes of sentencing set out in Article 51 and reflected in Articles 52–54 of the Criminal Code, its implementation in environmental cases may depart from these objectives. In particular, restoration may be understood as procedural settlement or financial compensation rather than scientifically verifiable ecological recovery. This study employs doctrinal legal research through statutory and conceptual approaches, drawing on green criminology, ecological justice, and critical legal studies to assess the coherence of the restorative justice framework with the characteristics of environmental crime. The analysis shows that environmental crimes differ from conventional offenses because they affect collective and diffuse victims, cause irreversible ecological degradation, and generate long-term public consequences. Such harms cannot be adequately remedied through negotiated settlements alone. The findings indicate that restorative mechanisms may legitimize corporate impunity when No. compensation is prioritized over ecological restoration and corporate accountability, notwithstanding the corporate criminal liability provisions under Law No. 32 of 2009. This article therefore develops the concept of “restorative injustice” to describe a condition in which justice is formally and procedurally achieved but substantively fails to restore ecological balance, secure corporate accountability, protect environmental sustainability, or safeguard the rights and welfare of present and future generations. It argues that restorative justice in environmental criminal law must be assessed not merely by settlement procedures or compensation payments, but by measurable ecological outcomes, meaningful accountability, and the protection of affected communities and ecosystems.
Article Metrics:
Last update:
Last update: 2026-11-18 14:34:10
The Authors submitting a manuscript do so on the understanding that if accepted for publication, copyright of the article shall be assigned to Masalah Masalah Hukum journal (MMH) and Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro as publisher of the journal. Copyright encompasses rights to reproduce and deliver the article in all form and media, including reprints, photographs, microfilms, and any other similar reproductions, as well as translations.
MMH journal and Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro and the Editors make every effort to ensure that no wrong or misleading data, opinions or statements be published in the journal. In any way, the contents of the articles and advertisements published in MMH journal are the sole responsibility of their respective authors and advertisers.
We strongly encourage that manuscripts be submitted to online journal system in http://ejournal.undip.ac.id/index.php/mmh/index. Authors are required to create an account and submit the manuscripts online. For submission inquiries, please follow the submission instructions in the website. If the author has any problems on the online submission, please contact Editorial Office at the following email: jurnal.mmh@undip.ac.id or jurnal.mmh@gmail.com
Contributors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce any materials, including photographs and illustrations, for which they do not hold the copyright and for ensuring that the appropriate acknowledgments are included in the manuscript.