skip to main content

RESTORATIVE JUSTICE OR ‘RESTORATIVE INJUSTICE’? EXAMINING NORMATIVE LIMITATIONS IN INDONESIA’S NEW PENAL CODE ON ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMIC CRIMES

*Jelita Kristi Agape  -  Faculty of Law, Universitas Sebelas Maret, Indonesia
Adi Sulistyono  -  Faculty of Law, Universitas Sebelas Maret, Indonesia
Muhammad Rustamaji  -  Faculty of Law, Universitas Sebelas Maret, Indonesia
Open Access Copyright (c) 2026 Masalah-Masalah Hukum under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0.

Citation Format:
Abstract

This article critically examines the application of restorative justice in Indonesian environmental criminal law under Law No. 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code and Law No. 32 of 2009 on Environmental Protection and Management. It focuses on how restorative justice may be transformed into “restorative injustice” in cases involving corporate environmental crimes and structural ecological damage. Although restorative justice is normatively supported by the purposes of sentencing set out in Article 51 and reflected in Articles 52–54 of the Criminal Code, its implementation in environmental cases may depart from these objectives. In particular, restoration may be understood as procedural settlement or financial compensation rather than scientifically verifiable ecological recovery. This study employs doctrinal legal research through statutory and conceptual approaches, drawing on green criminology, ecological justice, and critical legal studies to assess the coherence of the restorative justice framework with the characteristics of environmental crime. The analysis shows that environmental crimes differ from conventional offenses because they affect collective and diffuse victims, cause irreversible ecological degradation, and generate long-term public consequences. Such harms cannot be adequately remedied through negotiated settlements alone. The findings indicate that restorative mechanisms may legitimize corporate impunity when No. compensation is prioritized over ecological restoration and corporate accountability, notwithstanding the corporate criminal liability provisions under Law No. 32 of 2009. This article therefore develops the concept of “restorative injustice” to describe a condition in which justice is formally and procedurally achieved but substantively fails to restore ecological balance, secure corporate accountability, protect environmental sustainability, or safeguard the rights and welfare of present and future generations. It argues that restorative justice in environmental criminal law must be assessed not merely by settlement procedures or compensation payments, but by measurable ecological outcomes, meaningful accountability, and the protection of affected communities and ecosystems.

Keywords: Restorative Justice; Restorative Injustice; Environmental Criminal Law; Corporate Criminal Liability; Ecological Justice

Article Metrics:

  1. Agusta, E. N. (2024). Embracing Restorative Justice: A Path Towards Equitable Mediation in Criminal Cases. Jurnal Hukum Progresif, 12(1), 56–65. https://doi.org/10.14710/jhp.12.1.56-65
  2. Alba-Patiño, D., Martín-López, B., Delibes-Mateos, M., Requena-Mullor, J. M., & Castro, A. J. (2025). Environmental Justice Gaps in Human-Wildlife Conflict Research from a Social-Ecological Systems Perspective. Biological Conservation, 312, 111515. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2025.111515
  3. Andriyani, L., Gunawan, M. M., & Manitra, R. R. M. (2026). Restorative Justice in Criminal Cases in Indonesia: The Urgency of Reinterpretation and Concept for Reform. Indonesian Journal of Crime and Criminal Justice, 2(1), 154–195. https://doi.org/10.62264/ijccj.v2i1.167
  4. Arifin, R., Umbría, C. N., & Cassandro, I. M. (2026). Penal Culture and Judicial Responses to Environmental Crimes: Lessons from Indonesian Environmental Courts. Indonesian Journal of Environmental Law and Sustainable Development, 5(1), 303–371. https://doi.org/10.15294/ijel.v5i1.45608
  5. Arnscheidt, J. (2009). ‘Debating’ Nature Conservation: Policy, Law and Practice in Indonesia: A Discourse Analysis of History and Present [Doctoral thesis, Leiden University Press]. https://scholarlypublications.universiteitleiden.nl/handle/1887/21162
  6. Aswandi, A. (2022). Interpretasi Pemikiran Hukum Kritis terhadap Kebijakan Perlindungan Lingkungan Hidup dalam Hukum Positif di Indonesia. Tanjungpura Law Journal, 6(2), 163–178. https://doi.org/10.26418/tlj.v6i2.50516
  7. Bara, F., Tallo, D. D., & Amalo, H. (2024). Penerapan Transtheoretical Theory dan Reintegrative Shaming Theory terhadap Rehabilitasi dan Reintegrasi Sosial BNNP NTT. Artemis Law Journal, 1(2), 456–469. https://doi.org/10.35508/alj.v1i2.14819
  8. Baumane-Vitolina, I., Cals, I., & Sumilo, E. (2016). Is Ethics Rational? Teleological, Deontological and Virtue Ethics Theories Reconciled in the Context of Traditional Economic Decision Making. Procedia Economics and Finance, 39, 108–114. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2212-5671(16)30249-0
  9. Boulot, E. (2025). The Environmental Statehood of Ecological Restoration: An Institutional Analysis of Three Regulatory Case Studies. Global Environmental Change, 91, 102982. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2025.102982
  10. Braithwaite, J. (1989). Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Cambridge University Press
  11. Budiyanto, B., & Pondayar, Y. (2026). Conceptualizing the Integration of Restorative Justice in Environmental Crimes into Customary Criminal Justice. Journal of Law, Environmental and Justice, 4(1), 124–160. https://doi.org/10.62264/jlej.v4i1.204
  12. Choi, Y. D. (2007). Restoration Ecology to the Future: A Call for New Paradigm. Restoration Ecology, 15(2), 351–353. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1526-100X.2007.00224.x
  13. Darmawan, R. A., Diputra, M. M. R., Rahman, A., & Sutrisno, A. (2024). Analysis of the Effectiveness of the Application of Restorative Justice in Criminal Cases in Indonesia. Journal of World Science, 3(5), 567–572. https://doi.org/10.58344/jws.v3i5.612
  14. Doelman, J. C., Verhagen, W., Stehfest, E., & van Vuuren, D. P. (2023). The Role of Peatland Degradation, Protection and Restoration for Climate Change Mitigation in the SSP Scenarios. Environmental Research: Climate, 2(3), 035002. https://doi.org/10.1088/2752-5295/acd5f4
  15. Faisal, Yanto, A., Rahayu, D. P., Haryadi, D., Darmawan, A., & Manik, J. D. N. (2024). Genuine Paradigm of Criminal Justice: Rethinking Penal Reform Within Indonesia New Criminal Code. Cogent Social Sciences, 10(1), 2301634. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2023.2301634
  16. Fernando, Z. J., Dahwal, S., Arifin, F., Maskur, M. A., & Muthia, A. A. (2025). Advancing Ecological Justice through the Integration of Eco-Religion in Criminal Law Reform. Journal of Law, Environmental and Justice, 3(2), 160–200. https://doi.org/10.62264/jlej.v3i2.133
  17. Fernando, Z. J., Sinaga, L. V., Iskandar, Mardin, N., & Arifin, F. (2025). Environment as a Legal Subject in the Reconstruction of Indonesia’s Environmental Law. Indonesian Journal of Environmental Law and Sustainable Development, 4(1), 95–122. https://doi.org/10.15294/ijel.v4i1.20146
  18. Forsyth, M., & Tepper, F. (2024). Environmental Enforceable Undertakings: An Innovative Tool to Repair and Prevent Environmental Harm. Journal of Environmental Law, 36(3), 385–411. https://doi.org/10.1093/jel/eqae021
  19. Gowdy, J., Howarth, R. B., Tisdell, C., Arnoldus, P., Hansjürgens, B., Hepburn, C., McNeely, J. A., & Mäler, K.-G. (2011). Discounting, Ethics and Options for Maintaining Biodiversity and Ecosystem Integrity. In P. Kumar (Ed.), The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity: Ecological and Economic Foundations (Chapter 6, pp. 257–283). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781849775489-7
  20. Hamilton, M. (2021). Environmental Crime and Restorative Justice: Justice as Meaningful Involvement (1st edn). Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-69052-6
  21. Härter, K. (2023). Insane Offenders, Dangerous Criminals, Criminal Responsibility and Security Measures: The Positivist Criminology Network and the Reform of Criminal Law in Imperial Germany. GLOSSAE. European Journal of Legal History, 20, 67–94. https://glossae.eu/glossaeojs/article/view/584
  22. Hrishakov, M. V. (2023). Interpol Activities against Environmental Crime. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod National University. Series: Law, 80(2), 290–295. https://doi.org/10.24144/2307-3322.2023.80.2.47
  23. Isdiyanto, I. Y. (2025). Max Weber vs Émile Durkheim: Pertarungan Paradigma dalam Sosiologi Hukum di Indonesia. Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan, 55(2). https://doi.org/10.21143/jhp.vol55.no.2.1782
  24. Karianga, H., Akbar, A., & Fenitra, R. M. (2025). Reforming the Ecological Fiscal Transfer Mechanism: Towards a Sustainable Regional Fiscal Policy in Indonesia. Journal of Law, Environmental and Justice, 3(3), 608–640. https://doi.org/10.62264/jlej.v3i3.200
  25. Klimek, L. (2026). Strengthening Environmental Protection Through Criminal Law in Europe: Normative Shifts and Enforcement Implications. Access to Justice in Eastern Europe, 9(2), 11–34. https://doi.org/10.33327/AJEE-18-9.2-a000193
  26. Kurniawan, A., Hendri, K., Hadi, S., Harahap, A. P., & Burhanuddin, B. (2025). Recolonizing Formal Restorative Justice: A Socio-Legal Critique of Indonesia’s Shift from Customary Justice to State Law. Diponegoro Law Review, 10(2), 294–309. https://doi.org/10.14710/dilrev.10.2.2025.294-309
  27. Li, G., Wen, H., Sun, Q., & Xue, J. (2025). The Role of the Digital Economy in Promoting Energy Justice: Evidence from Procedural Justice and Restorative Justice. China Economic Review, 89, 102334. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2024.102334
  28. Liu, Y., Zhang, J., Liu, C., & Yang, Y. (2024). A Review of Attention Restoration Theory: Implications for Designing Restorative Environments. Sustainability, 16(9), 3639. https://doi.org/10.3390/su16093639
  29. Lynch, M. J. (2020). Green Criminology and Environmental Crime: Criminology That Matters in the Age of Global Ecological Collapse. Journal of White Collar and Corporate Crime, 1(1), 50–61. https://doi.org/10.1177/2631309X19876930
  30. Lynch, M. J., & Stretesky, P. B. (2014). Exploring Green Criminology: Toward a Green Criminological Revolution. Ashgate. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315581644
  31. Mahmutovic, A., & Alhamoudi, A. (2024). Understanding the Relationship Between the Rule of Law and Sustainable Development. Access to Justice in Eastern Europe, 7(1), 170–197. https://doi.org/10.33327/AJEE-18-7.1-a000102
  32. Malau, P. (2023). Tinjauan Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana (KUHP) Baru 2023. AL-MANHAJ: Jurnal Hukum dan Pranata Sosial Islam, 5(1), 837–844. https://doi.org/10.37680/almanhaj.v5i1.2815
  33. Mulyono, G. P., Putri, N. L. P. A., Rifandhana, R. F., & Douglas, H. (2026). Integrating Pancasila Justice in Sentencing Balinese Customary Crimes: Toward an Integrative Model Under Indonesia’s New Criminal Code. Jurnal Hukum Progresif, 14(1), 84–121. https://doi.org/10.14710/jhp.14.1.84-121
  34. Nasution, M. I., Ali, M., & Lubis, F. (2024). Pembaruan Sistem Pemidanaan di Indonesia: Kajian Literatur atas KUHP Baru. Judge: Jurnal Hukum, 5(1), 16–23. https://journal.cattleyadf.org/index.php/Judge/article/view/507
  35. Ndaru, F. A. (2025). Restorative Environmental Law Enforcement: Ensuring Environmental Restoration and Compliance Through Multiple Legal Instruments. Asia Pacific Fraud Journal, 10(2), 191–208. https://doi.org/10.21532/apfjournal.v10i2.379
  36. Nelson, V. (2025). From Control to Care: Trans-Hegemonic Approaches to Just-Sustainability Transformations. Environmental Science & Policy, 171, 104115. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2025.104115
  37. Noor, S., Banapon, K. I., & Levis, T. K. (2025). Distorted Practice of Restorative Justice in the Enforcement of Criminal Law in Indonesia: Distorsi Praktik Restorative Justice dalam Penegakan Hukum Pidana di Indonesia. Peradaban Hukum Nusantara, 2(1), 15–33. https://doi.org/10.62193/ze7dhp98
  38. Pardede, J. N., & Santoso, W. Y. (2022). Refleksi Kritis Terhadap Konsep Keadilan Restoratif dalam Penanganan Tindak Pidana Lingkungan Hidup di Indonesia. Jurnal Hukum Lingkungan Indonesia, 8(2), 263–286. https://doi.org/10.38011/jhli.v8i2.390
  39. Percival, R. V., Schroeder, C. H., Miller, A. S., & Leape, J. P. (2024). Environmental Regulation: Law, Science, and Policy (10th edn). Aspen Publishing. https://aspenpublishing.com/products/percival-environmentallaw10
  40. Petersmann, M.-C. (2021). Response-Abilities of Care in More-Than-Human Worlds. Journal of Human Rights and the Environment, 12(0), 102–124. https://doi.org/10.4337/jhre.2021.00.05
  41. Porfido, S. (2021). The Use of Restorative Justice for Environmental Crimes in the European Union’s Legal Framework. Queen Mary Law Journal, 2021(1), 106–133. https://doi.org/10.26494/QMLJ72469
  42. Procter-Legg, T., Hobson, J., & Quimby, E. (2024). Restorative Justice and Social Justice: An International Perspective. Contemporary Justice Review, 27(2–3), 218–238. https://doi.org/10.1080/10282580.2024.2414953
  43. Putra, A. W. (2025). Environmental Restoration as a Principal Punishment in Indonesia Environmental Crimes: Restorative Justice in Formulation. 4th International Conference on Law, Economic, and Governance (ICOLEG 2025), 1537(1). https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/1537/1/012066
  44. Quintas-Soriano, C., Brandt, J. S., Running, K., Baxter, C. V., Gibson, D. M., Narducci, J., & Castro, A. J. (2018). Social-Ecological Systems Influence Ecosystem Service Perception: A Programme on Ecosystem Change and Society (PECS) Analysis. Ecology and Society, 23(3), 3. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-10226-230303
  45. Rahardjo, S. (2007). Hukum Progresif Berdamai dengan Alam. Jurnal Hukum Progresif, 3(2), 1. https://doi.org/10.14710/hp.3.2.1
  46. Rahardjo, S. (2011). Hukum Progresif: Hukum yang Membebaskan. Jurnal Hukum Progresif, 1(1), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.14710/hp.1.1.1-24
  47. Rahmad, N., & Hafis, W. (2021). Hukum Progresif dan Relevansinya pada Penalaran Hukum di Indonesia. EL-AHLI: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Islam, 1(2), 34–50. https://doi.org/10.56874/el-ahli.v1i2.133
  48. Rahmah, M., Nurleli, Sahrizal, Anggara, R., & Hatta, M. (2025). The Analysis of Damages and Remedies In Environmental Law: Case Study of PT. Kallista Alam. International Journal of Law, Social Science, and Humanities, 2(3), 339–347. https://doi.org/10.70193/ijlsh.v2i3.243
  49. Rebhi, T. (2024). Interpol’s Global Efforts to Combat Organized Crime Examining Strategies and Impact. Revue Critique De Droit Et Sciences Politiques, 19(1), 99–111. https://asjp.cerist.dz/en/article/241796
  50. Saputra, K., Saefudin, Y., Soediro, Rusli, H., & Armansyah. (2026). Communal Justice for Environmental Sustainability in Indonesia’s New Criminal Code: Challenges in Law Enforcement. Journal of Law, Environmental and Justice, 4(1), 161–207. https://doi.org/10.62264/jlej.v4i1.221
  51. Saputra, R., Permana, G., & Lestari, A. (2026). The Role of Restorative Justice in Reforming the Indonesian Criminal Justice System. Journal of Lex et Justitia, 2(1), 66–80. https://doi.org/10.67171/vkgwrq81
  52. Sembada, P., Karjoko, L., & Kusomo, A. T. S. (2025). Implementation of Law and Justice in Indonesia: Between Formalistic Paradigm and Substantive Justice. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Law, Economics & Good Governance (ICLAW 2025), 340–344. https://doi.org/10.2991/978-2-38476-519-5_27
  53. Shamsidinov, Z., Kholmirzaev, U., Khakimov, K., Abzalova, K., Khaydarov, S., Sunnatov, V., Mamajanov, A., Allanova, A., Toshev, O., & Kurbanov, M. (2025). Compensation Over Justice: Inequalities in Uzbekistan’s Restorative Practices. Crime, Law and Social Change, 84(1), 4. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-025-10255-0
  54. Shover, N., & Routhe, A. S. (2005). Environmental Crime. Crime and Justice, 32, 321–371. https://doi.org/10.1086/655356
  55. Siahaan, J. D. P., & Yudiantara, I. G. N. N. K. (2025). Penerapan Nilai-Nilai Crime Control Model (CCM) dan Due Process Model (DPM) dalam Sistem Peradilan Pidana di Indonesia. Jurnal Media Akademik (JMA), 3(7), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.62281/v3i7.2555
  56. Syaifullah. (2026). Transformation of the Sentencing Paradigm in Indonesia: A Juridical Study of the Implementation of Restorative Justice in the New Criminal Code. Journal of Indonesian Comparative of Syari’ah Law, 9(1), 36–48. https://doi.org/10.21111/jicl.v9i1.14
  57. Syam, A. (2022). Measuring the Concept of Restoration in Criminal Justice System. Jurnal Ilmiah Kebijakan Hukum, 16(2), 363–376. https://doi.org/10.30641/kebijakan.2022.V16.363-376
  58. Tekayadi, S. K., Wiswa, I. N. A. S., & Ramadhoan, Muh. Z. (2025). Characteristics of Victims of Environmental Crime in Indonesia. Lex Journal: Kajian Hukum Dan Keadilan, 9(4), 735–747. https://doi.org/10.25139/lex.v9i4.11141
  59. Ufran, & Amaral, A. D. (2019). Initiating the Utilization of Restorative Justice in Completing of the Environmental Crime Cases. Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan, 49(3), 665–681. https://doi.org/10.21143/jhp.vol49.no3.1205
  60. Ulinihayati, N., & Saleh, M. A. (2025). The Restorative Justice in the Environmental Crimes as an Effort to Achieve the Intergenerational Environmental Justice. 1537(1). https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/1537/1/012063
  61. Umbreit, M., & Armour, M. P. (2010). Restorative Justice Dialogue: An Essential Guide for Research and Practice. Springer publishing company
  62. United Nations Environment Programme & INTERPOL. (2016, June 4). UNEP-INTERPOL Report: Value of Environmental Crime up 26%. United Nations Environment Programme. https://www.unep.org/en/news-and-stories/press-release/unep-interpol-report-value-environmental-crime-26
  63. van Uhm, D. (2024). Green Criminology and Biodiversity Loss: Crimes and Harms against Flora and Fauna. In H. N. Pontell (Ed.), Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice (p. 0). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264079.013.763
  64. White, R. (2013). Crimes Against Nature: Environmental Criminology and Ecological Justice. Routledge
  65. White, R. (2014). Environmental Insecurity and Fortress Mentality. International Affairs, 90(4), 835–851. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2346.12143
  66. Wong, E. W. (2026). Environment Protection Authority V Forestry Corporation of NSW: Amici Curiae and Restorative Environmental Justice. Journal of Environmental Law, 38(2), 296–305. https://doi.org/10.1093/jel/eqag005
  67. Zahroh, U. A., & Najicha, F. U. (2022). Problems and Challenges on Environmental Law Enforcement in Indonesia: AMDAL in the Context of Administrative Law. Indonesian State Law Review, 5(2), 53–66. https://doi.org/10.15294/islrev.v5i2.46511
  68. Zębek, E., & Solodov, D. (2026). The EU Environmental Crime Directive 2024/1203: Legal Solutions and Perspectives. Journal for Nature Conservation, 89, 127093. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnc.2025.127093
  69. Zehr, H. (1990). Changing Lenses: A New Focus for Crime and Justice (3rd revised). Herald Press

Last update:

No citation recorded.

Last update: 2026-11-18 14:34:10

No citation recorded.