DOI: https://doi.org/10.14710/lr.v20i2.59273

Legal Mechanisms for Business Accountability: A Comparison of Soft and Hard Law in Indonesia

*Henry Aspan orcid scopus  -  Faculty of Social Science, Universitas Pembangunan Panca Budi &Faculty of Business and Accountancy, Lincoln University College, Malaysia
Rozaini Rosli orcid  -  Faculty of Business and Accountancy, Lincoln University College, Malaysia
Fadlan Fadlan  -  Faculty of Law, Universitas Batam, Indonesia
Irawati Irawati scopus  -  Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro, Indonesia
Open Access Copyright 2024 LAW REFORM under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0.

How to cite (IEEE): H. Aspan, R. Rosli, F. Fadlan, and I. Irawati, "Legal Mechanisms for Business Accountability: A Comparison of Soft and Hard Law in Indonesia," LAW REFORM, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 353-382, Oct. 2024. https://doi.org/10.14710/lr.v20i2.59273
Citation Format:
Abstract

This research investigates the legal mechanisms for business accountability in the context of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in Indonesia through a comparative study of soft and hard law approaches. The study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of these approaches in promoting business accountability within the Indonesian framework. The research methodology relies on secondary data analysis, including a comprehensive review of existing legal frameworks and regulations related to CSR, as well as an examination of relevant case studies and empirical data. The findings reveal that hard law, characterized by binding regulations and clear sanctions, is more effective in promoting business accountability. However, soft law plays a vital role by offering guidance and incentives for companies to adopt broader social responsibility practices. Cultural factors, the legal environment, and the roles of the government and civil society organizations influence the effectiveness of these approaches. The study highlights the importance of combining hard and soft law approaches in CSR regulation. Recommendations include strengthening monitoring and enforcement by government agencies, offering more substantial incentives, and creating a supportive legal environment. Additionally, companies should understand and respect local culture and commit to anti-corruption efforts. Collaborative efforts among the government, businesses, and civil society are essential for establishing a more sustainable and accountable business environment in Indonesia.

Fulltext View|Download
Keywords: Legal Mechanism; Business Accountability; Soft Law; Hard Law; Indonesian Law

Article Metrics:

Article Info
Section: Research Article
Language : EN
Recent articles
Problems of Equality in the Realisation of the Right to Association in Kazakhstan Discretion of Government Officials Detrimental to State Finances: The Intersection Between Administrative Illegality and Criminal Illegality Law Enforcement in the Recovery of State Funds from Corruption Crimes More recent articles
Most cited articles
PENDIDIKAN HUKUM SEBAGAI PENDIDIKAN MANUSIA PRIVATISASI BADAN USAHA MILIK NEGARA KEBIJAKAN FORMULASI HUKUM PIDANA DALAM MELINDUNGI TRANSAKSI E - COMMERCE DI INDONESIA IMPLEMENTASI PENILAIAN KEBARUAN DAN PRINSIP ITIKAD BAIK DALAM PERLINDUNGAN DESAIN INDUSTRI COUNTER TERRORISM BAGI PELAKU TINDAK PIDANA TERORISME SEBAGAI UPAYA PENANGGULANGAN KEJAHATAN TERORISME DI INDONESIA More cited articles
  1. Achtouk-Spivak, Laurie., & Garden, Robert. (2022). OECD National Contact Point Specific Instances: When ’Soft Law’Bites?. Journal of International Dispute Settlement, Vol.13,(No.4),pp.608-642. https://doi.org/10.1093/jnlids/idac017
  2. Alvarez, Jose E. (2018). Reviewing the Use of “Soft Law” in Investment Arbitration. European International Arbitration Review, Vol.7.2. NYU School of Law, Public Law Research Paper No.18-46. https://ssrn.com/ abstract=3258737
  3. Amengual, Matthew., Mota, Rita., & Rustler, Alex. (2021). The ‘Court of Public Opinion:’ Public Perceptions of Business Involvement in Human Rights Violations. Journal of Business Ethics, Vol.185, pp.49-74. DOI: 10.1007/s10551-022-05147-5
  4. An, Nguyen B. (2021). Contemporary Legal Theories on Corporate Social Responsibility. Review of International Geographical Educational,Vol.11,(No.7). https://rigeo.org/menu-script/index.php/ rigeo/article/view/2648
  5. Arli, Denni., & Tjiptono, Fandy. (2014). Does Corporate Social Responsibility Matter to Consumers in Indonesia?. Social Responsibility Journal, Vol.10, (No.3), pp.537–49. DOI: 10.1108/srj-01-2013-0007
  6. Ayunda, R. (2022). Personal Data Protection to E-Commerce Consumer: What Are the Legal Challenges and Certainties?. Law Reform, Vol.18,(No.2),pp.144–63. DOI: 10.14710/lr.v18i2.43307
  7. Bansal, M. (2022). Impact of Mandatory CSR Spending on Strategic Brand‐building Levers: Evidence From a Quasi‐natural Experiment in India. Managerial and Decision Economics,Vol.43,(No.8),pp.3620–3633. DOI: 10.1002/mde.3618
  8. Benöhr, I. (2020). The United Nations Guidelines for Consumer Protection: Legal Implications and New Frontiers. Journal of Consumer Policy,Vol.43,(No.1),pp.105-124. DOI: 10.1007/s10603-019-09443-y
  9. Berger‐Walliser, Garlinde., & Scott, Inara (2018). Redefining Corporate Social Responsibility in an Era of Globalization and Regulatory Hardening. American Business Law Journal, Vol.55,(No.1),pp.167-218. DOI: 10.1111/ablj.12119
  10. Berning, Laila., & Sotirov, Metodi. (2023). Hardening Corporate Accountability in Commodity Supply Chains under the European Union Deforestation Regulation. Regulation and Governance, Vol.17, (No.4), pp.870-890. DOI: 10.1111/rego.12540
  11. Bhuiyan, Faruk., Baird Kevin., & Munir, Rahat. (2020). The Association Between Organisational Culture, CSR Practices and Organisational Performance in an Emerging Economy. Meditari Accountancy Research, Vol.28,(No.6),pp.977–1011. DOI: 10.1108/medar-09-2019-0574
  12. Boki, I. (2020). The Role of Investment Laws in Strengthening Corporate Social Responsibility: Ethiopia’s Investment Regime in Focus. Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization,Vol.100,(No.1),pp.23-30. DOI: 10.7176/JLPG/100-1
  13. Bortolotti, Thomas., Boscari, Stefania., & Danese, Pamela. (2015). Successful Lean Implementation: Organizational Culture and Soft Lean Practices. International Journal of Production Economics, Vol.160, (No.1), pp.182–201. DOI: 10.1016/j.ijpe.2014.10.013
  14. Chambers, Rachel., & Vastardis, Anil Yilmaz. (2020). Human Rights Disclosure and Due Diligence Laws: The Role of Regulatory Oversight in Ensuring Corporate Accountability. Chicago Journal of International Law, Vol.21, (No.2), pp.323-366. https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cjil/vol21/ iss2/4
  15. Chang, Soonpeel E. (2018). Has Indonesia’s Unique Progressivism in Mandating Corporate Social Responsibility Achieved Its Ends?. Sriwijaya Law Review, Vol. 2 (No.2), pp.131-151. DOI: 10.28946/slrev.vol2.iss2.131.pp131-151
  16. Choudhury, B. (2018). Balancing Soft and Hard Law for Business and Human Rights. International and Comparative Law Quarterly,Vol.67,(No.4),pp.1-26. DOI: 10.1017/S0020589318000155
  17. Cuomo, Francesca., Malin, Christine., & Zattoni, Alessandro. (2015). Corporate Governance Codes: A Review and Research Agenda. Corporate Governance: An International Review, Vol.24, (No.3), pp.222–241. DOI: 10.1111/corg.12148
  18. Dawood, S. (2021). Corporate Social Responsibility and MNCs: An Appraisal from Investment Treaty Law Perspective. Indonesian Journal of Law and Society, Vol.2,(No.2),pp.197-234. DOI: 10.19184/ijls.v2i2.24262
  19. Delalieux, Guillaume., & Moquet, Anne-Catherine (2020). French Law on CSR Due Diligence Paradox: The Institutionalization of Soft Law Mechanisms through the Law. Society and Business Review, Vol.15, (No.2), pp.125-143. DOI: 10.1108/SBR-03-2019-0033
  20. Dharmawan, Ni Ketut Supasti., Kasih, Desak Putu Dewi., Kurniawan, I Gede Agus., & Samsithawrati, Putra Aras. (2018). The Guiding Principles On Business And Human Rights: National Action Plans Toward Corporation Responsibility. Hasanuddin Law Review, Vol.4, (No.2), pp.123-145. DOI: 10.20956/halrev.v4i2.1480
  21. Disemadi, Hari S. (2022). Contextualization of Legal Protection of Intellectual Property in Micro Small and Medium Enterprises in Indonesia. Law Reform, Vol.18, (No.1), pp.89–110. DOI: 10.14710/lr.v18i1.42568
  22. Djayaputra, G. (2021). Analysis of Natural Resources Management in Indonesia: Environmental Law Perspective. International Journal of Social Science and Public Policy (IJSSPP), Vol.3, (No.1), pp.3-12. DOI: 10.33642/ijsspp.v3n1p1
  23. Gilbert, Dirk Ulrich., & Huber, Kristin. (2023). Labour Rights in Global Supply Chains. Corporate Responsibility, Cambridge University Press, Vol.79, (No.2), pp.456-483. DOI-10.2139/ssrn.3517235
  24. Halkos, George., & Nomikos, Stylianos. (2021). Reviewing the Status of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Legal Framework. Management of Environmental Quality an International Journal, Vol.32, (No.4), pp.700–716. DOI: 10.1108/meq-04-2021-0073
  25. Hartiwiningsih., Gumbira, Seno Wibowo., & Barkhuizen, Jaco. (2023). Dysfunctional Factors of Environmental Law on Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation and Developing Remedial Strategies Through Reconstruction Criminal Law System Model in Indonesia. Padjadjaran Jurnal Ilmu Hukum,Vol.10,(No.3),pp.411–30. DOI: 10.22304/pjih.v10n3.a6
  26. Indriastuti, Maya., & Chariri, Andi. (2021), The Role Of Green Investment And Corporate Social Responsibility Investment On Sustainable Performance, Cogent Business and Management, Vol.8, Issue 1. DOI: 10.1080/23311975.2021.1960120
  27. Jackson, Kevin T. (2016). Cosmopolitan Jurisprudence for Economic Governance. Society and Business Review, Vol.11, (No.3),pp.276–96. DOI: 10.1108/sbr-08-2015-0041
  28. Joseph, Sarah., & Kyriakakis, Joanna (2023). From Soft Law to Hard Law in Business and Human Rights and the Challenge of Corporate Power. Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol.36, (No.2), pp.335-361. DOI: 10.1017/S0922156522000826
  29. Kalyar, Masood Nawaz., Rafi, Nosheen., & Kalyar, Awais Nawaz. (2012). Factors Affecting Corporate Social Responsibility: An Empirical Study. Systems Research and Behavioral Science, Vol.30, (No.4), pp.495–505. https://doi.org/10.1002/sres.2134
  30. Kasih, Desak Putu Dewi., Salain, Made Suksma Prijandhini Devi., Sudiarawan, Kadek Agus., Dwijayanthi, Putri Triari., Sawitri, Dewa Ayu Dian., & Pratama, Alvyn Chaisar Perwira Nanggala. (2022). Classification of Industrial Relations Disputes Settlement in Indonesia: Is It Necessary?. Hasanuddin Law Review, Vol.8,(No.1),pp.79–94. http://dx.doi.org/10.20956/halrev.v8i1.3502
  31. Kencana, Ulya., Sirozi, Muhammad., & Muchtar, Aflatun. (2018). Corporate Social Responsibility in Indonesia Law and Legal Validity. Russian Law Journal, Vol.11, (No.3),pp.1811-1825. https://repository.radenfatah.ac.id/27981/1/10.%2BRLJ_Akun%2BSubmit.pdf
  32. Leka, Stavroula., Jain, Aditya., Lavicoli, Sergio, & Tecco, Cristina Di. (2015). An Evaluation of the Policy Context on Psychosocial Risks and Mental Health in the Workplace in the European Union: Achievements, Challenges, and the Future. Biomed Research International, Vol.2015, (No.1), pp.1–18. DOI: 10.1155/2015/213089
  33. Lie, Luther., & Dewi, Yetty Komalasari. (2021). An Ineffective Institutional Investors Law in Indonesia? Why Bother. Indonesia Law Review,Vol.11,(No.3),pp.231-248. DOI: 10.15742/ilrev.v11n3.1
  34. Lisnawati, D. (2024). Legal Protection of Investors on the Lajnah Bisnis Syariah (Lbs) Platforem. Jurnal Justisia Ekonomika Magister Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, Vol.8, (No.1),pp.1001–12, DOI: 10.30651/justeko.v8i1.21870
  35. Nurhayati, Yati., Ifrani., & Said, M. Yasir. (2021). Metodologi Normatif Dan Empiris Dalam Perspektif Ilmu Hukum. Jurnal Penegakan Hukum Indonesia, Vol.2, (No.1), pp.1–20. DOI: 10.51749/jphi.v2i1.14
  36. Parella, K. (2020). Symposium on Soft and Hard Law on Business and Human Rights. Hard and Soft Law Preferences in Business and Human Rights. American Journal of International Law Unbound, Vol.114, pp.168–73. DOI: 10.1017/aju.2020.33
  37. Pascal, Ana-M. (2021). Business and Human Rights, from Theory to Practice and Law to Morality: Taking a Philosophical Look at the Proposed UN Treaty. Philosophy of Management, Vol.20, (No.2), pp.167-200. DOI: 10.1007/s40926-020-00150-0
  38. Payne, Leigh A., & Pereira, Gabriel. (2016). Corporate Complicity in International Human Rights Violations. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, Vol.12, (No.1), pp.63–84.DOI: 10.1146/annurev-lawsocsci-110615-085100
  39. Pramudianto, A. (2018). ASEAN Commitment to Sustainable Development in the Regional International Environmental Law Perspective. International Relations and Diplomacy,Vol.6,(No.3),pp.171-187. DOI: 10.17265/2328-2134/2018.03.003
  40. Prasetio, Januar Eko., Sabihaini., Bintarto, Bambang., Susanto, Anindyo Aji., & Rahmanda, Gita Astyka. (2021). Mandatory Corporate Social Responsibility Explanation. RSF Conference Series Business Management and Social Sciences, Vol.1, (No.3),pp.71-166. DOI: 10.31098/bmss.v1i3.315
  41. Putri, Luh Putu Yeyen Karista., Imarhiagbe, Miriam., Mandira, I Made Chandra., Withnall, Eric Gordon., & Duarsa, Putu Yasodhara Sthita Brahmani. (2023). Comparative Analysis of Indonesia’s Minimum Capital Requirements for Foreign Direct Investment. Lex Scientia Law Review, Vol.7,(No.1),pp.179-214. DOI: 10.15294/lesrev.v7i1.64664
  42. Ratmono, Dwi., Nugrahini, D.E., & Cahyonowati, Nur. (2021), The Effect of Corporate Governance on Corporate Social Responsibility Disclosure and Performance. Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business, Vol.8, Issue 2, pp.933-941. DOI: 10.13106/jafeb.2021.vol8.no2.0933
  43. Rinawiyanti, Esti Dwi., Huang, Xueli., & As-Saber, Sharif. (2021). The impacts of corporate social responsibility on small and medium enterprises performance. Estudios de Economia Aplicada, Vol.39, (No,12), pp.2-13. DOI: 10.25115/eea.v39i12.6025
  44. Rofingi., Rozah, Umi., & Asga, Adifyan Rahmat. (2022). Problems of Law Enforcement in Realizing The Principle of Equality Before The Law in Indonesia. Law Reform, Vol.18, (No.2),pp.222–237. DOI: 10.14710/lr.v18i2.47477
  45. Rosser, Andrew., Macdonald, Kate., & Setiawan, Ken MP. (2022). Implementing the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: Insights from Indonesia. Human Rights Quarterly, Vol.44, (No.1),pp.56-80. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.2022.0002
  46. Rudy., Natamiharja, Rudi., Sernac, Jalil Alejandro Magaldi., & Syofyan, Ahmad. (2022). Implementation of Civil Rights against Vulnerable Groups in the Legal and Constitutional System in Indonesia. Hasanuddin Law Review, Vol.8, (No.3), pp. 299–309. http://dx.doi.org/10.20956/halrev.v8i3.4229
  47. Sahoo, S. (2019). Lean Manufacturing Practices and Performance: The Role of Social and Technical Factors. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, Vol.37, (No.5), pp.732–54. DOI: 10.1108/ijqrm-03-2019-0099
  48. Santoso, B. (2022). Criticism on the Legislative Approach to Fostering CSR in Indonesia. Journal of Legal Ethical and Regulatory Issues,Vol.25,(No.2),pp.1-11, DOI: 10.1544/jleri.0044.25.156
  49. Sari, Maya., Lubis, A de Fatma., Maksum, Azhar., & Lumbanraja, Prihatin. (2018). The Influence of Organization’s Culture and Internal Control to Corporate Governance and is Impact on Bumn (State-Owned Enterprises) Corporate Performance in Indonesia. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, Vol.9, (No.2), pp.681-691. DOI: 10.17826/jarle.v77n1.37210
  50. Sheehy, Benedict., Tuslian, Widya., & Lie, Luther. (2021). The Use of International Soft Law for Corporate Social Responsibility Reporting in the Retail Industry: A Study of Four Major Retailers in the Asia-Pacific. Canberra Law Review,Vol.18,(No.1),pp.60-80. DOI: 10.3316/agis.20211119057017
  51. Simons, P. (2023). Developments in Canada on Business and Human Rights: One Step Forward Two Steps Back. Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol.36, (No.2), pp.363-388. DOI: 10.1017/S0922156522000784
  52. Sitabuana, Tundjung Herning., Adhari, Ade., Suryani, Leony Sondang., Sanjaya, Dixon., & Amri, Ibra Fulenzi. (2023). Measuring The Effectiveness of Private Electronic System Organizers Regulations In Developing Social Media Equilibrium. Law Reform, Vol.19,(No.2),pp.344–371. DOI: 10.14710/lr.v19i2.56534
  53. Sornarajah, M. (2020). Disintegration and Change in the International Law on Foreign Investment. Journal of International Economic Law, Vol.23, (No.2), pp.413-429. DOI: 10.1093/jiel/jgaa014
  54. Supriyadi. (2024). Legal Effectiveness of Halal Product Certification in Improving Business Economics in Indonesia and Malaysia. Al-Ahkam,Vol.34,(No.1),pp.193–220. DOI: 10.21580/ahkam.2024.34.1.20546
  55. Szablowski, D. (2019). ‘Legal Enclosure’ and Resource Extraction: Territorial Transformation through the Enclosure of Local and Indigenous Law. The Extractive Industries and Society, Vol.6, (No.3), pp.722-732. DOI: 10.1016/j.exis.2018.12.005
  56. Taduri, Januari Nasya A. (2021). The Legal Certainty and Protection of Foreign Investment Againsts Investment Practices in Indonesia. Lex Scientia Law Review, Vol.5, (No.1),pp.119–138. DOI: 10.15294/lesrev.v5i1.46286
  57. Vlahna, Kastriote., & Kuçi, Hajredin. (2022). The Creation of the Right of Real Servitude: Derivative and Original Method Based on the Kosovo and Some European Countries. Hasanuddin Law Review, Vol.8, (No.2), pp.111–121. DOI: 0.20956/halrev.v8i2.3614
  58. Waagstein, Patricia R. (2010). The Mandatory Corporate Social Responsibility in Indonesia: Problems and Implications. Journal of Business Ethics, Vol.98, (No.3), pp.455–466. DOI: 10.1007/s10551-010-0587-x
  59. Wirba, Asan V. (2023). Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR): The Role of Government in Promoting CSR. Journal of the Knowledge Economy, Vol.15, pp.7428-7454. DOI: 10.1007/s13132-023-01185-0
  60. Wulandari, Rini., & Dermawan, Mohammad Kemal. (2022). Construction of Anti-Money Laundering Policy in Indonesia from an International Law. Baltic Journal of Law & Politics, Vol.15, (No.4), pp.1179-1199. DOI: 10.bjlp.1319.v10j1
  61. Xiong, Ping., & Tomasic, Roman. (2019). Soft Law, State-Owned Enterprises and Dispute Resolution on PRC’s Belt and Road-towards an Emerging Legal Order?. Hong Kong Law Journal,Vol.49,(No.3),pp.1025-1056. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3505770
  62. Yasa, Putu Gede Arya Sumerta., Monteiro, Seguito., Atmaja, Bima Kumara Dwi., Sudiarawan, Kadek Agus., & Padmawati, Ni Komang Tari. (2022). Automatic Exchange of Information (AEoI) for Indonesian Tax Purposes: Economic Analysis of Law Approach. Lex Scientia Law Review, Vol.6, (No.1),pp.157–186. DOI: 10.15294/lesrev.v6i1.55143
  63. Yuliantiningsih, Aryuni., Suherman, Ade Maman., & Jati, Baginda Khalid Hidayat. (2021). Marine Plastic Pollution Handling Based on International and Indonesian Law to Support Sustainable Development Goals. Unifikasi; Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, Vol.10, (No.1), pp.58-73. DOI: 10.25134/unifikasi.v10i1.7498
  64. Zainal, Rabin I. (2019). Analysis of CSR Legislation in Indonesia: Mandate to Business. Business and Economic Research, Vol.9, (No.3), pp.165-181. DOI: 10.5296/ber.v9i3.14978
  65. Zhao, Jingchen., & Wen, Shuangge. (2022). Corporate Social Accountability. Stanford Journal of International Law, Vol.58, (No.1), pp.63-111. https://law.stanford.edu/publications/corporate-social-accountability/
  66. Ali, Z. (2021). Metode Penelitian Hukum. Jakarta: Sinar Grafika
  67. Bernasconi-Osterwalder, N. (2020). Inclusion of Investor Obligations and Corporate Accountability Provisions in Investment Agreements. Singapore : Springer
  68. Dube, I. (2019). Transnational Corporations’ Social License to Operate—The Third Facet of Corporate Governance. India: Springer
  69. George, E. (2021). Incorporating Rights: Strategies to Advance Corporate Accountability. New York: Oxford University Press
  70. Ho, Jean., & Sattorova, Mavluda. (2021). Investors’ International Law. London: Hart Publishing
  71. Sukdeo, V. (2019). Corporate Law, Codes of Conduct and Workers’ Rights. London: Routledge
  72. Baleva, Mary Kristerie A. (2018). Soft Law and Hard Realities: The UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. In Regaining Paradise Lost: Indigenous Land Rights and Tourism (pp. 59-108). Brill
  73. Ekhator, Eghosa O., & Iyiola-Omisore, I. (2021). Corporate Social Responsibility in the Oil and Gas Industry in Nigeria: The Case for a Legalised Framework. In: Pereira, E.G., Spencer, R., Moses, J.W. (eds) Sovereign Wealth Funds, Local Content Policies and CSR (pp. 439-458) CSR, Sustainability, Ethics & Governance. Switzerland: Springer, Cham
  74. Evanty, Nukila., & Ghufron, Nurul. (2021). Multinational Corporations and Human Rights in Indonesia: The Need for Improvement in Legislation. In Gomez, J., Ramcharan, R. (eds.), Business and Human Rights in Asia (pp.53-69). Palgrave Macmillan. Singapore: Springer
  75. Robles-Elorza, David., San-Jose, Leire., & Urionabarrenetxea, Sara. (2020). Regulation of CSR from International, European, and Spanish Viewpoints. in: David Crowther & Shahla Seifi (ed.), The Palgrave Handbook of Corporate Social Responsibility (pp.887-909). Springer
  76. Waagstein, Patricia R. (2020). Human Rights Certification in Indonesia: Problems and Implications. In Advancing Rule of Law in a Global Context (pp. 262-269). CRC Press. London: Routledge

Last update:

No citation recorded.

Last update: 2025-03-14 06:04:12

No citation recorded.